The first three chapters were positively
brimming with great information, so I must limit myself and comment on only
two:
Cleary, we cannot prohibit children from
accessing social networking sites at home or even on the playground. And I understand the argument that we shouldn’t
block these sites at school because we need to engage students in a critical
dialogue about global and online citizenship. But allow me to take a step back and say that these sites
were blocked at my high school…and then again when I worked at MassMutual. I never questioned it! It seems intuitive for a school or
employer to block these sites as they are huge distractions and counteract
productivity. It is axiomatic to
say that educators must teach students to have a responsible global voice, but
had my school not blocked these sites (even as an honor roll high school
student) I would have been in the library during English class, not researching
as I should have been, but “stalking” my friends/acquaintances on Facebook
while my teacher wasn’t looking.
Is there a balance?
The internet is powerfully motivating for
students. It is heartwarming to
read stories of students who continue their learning experience after school
hours virtually. I never thought
to share a particular learning experience with virtual onlookers, who can pose
questions to the students. But
students who have had this experience (November’s duck hatching example) were
eager to answers these questions, yet less eager to answer the same questions
when posed by the teacher. What a
wonderful way to create INDEPENDENT learners!
Having an audience to share your work with
creates accountability, and is thus motivating. I’ve mentioned this idea before when I’ve discussed
publishing student work on a class website. However, November uses an analogy that draws a wonderful
parallel: the internet is similar
to an auditorium or a field.
Actors, singers, and athletes rehearse and practice, culminating in a
performance. In the classroom,
formal assessments are the performance.
It just makes sense to give the students an audience to share it with
(and it doesn’t hurt that is motivating!).
Ciao!
I think blocking certain sites in work environments is essential to maintaining employee productivity. It's so easy to just slip onto Facebook "just for a second" to see what our friends are up to. My husband works for one of the big insurance companies in Hartford and they block all of the social media sites by a strong firewall. He can't even access our home e-mail account on yahoo from work. When it comes to blocking certain sites in schools, though, I think administration should re-think their reasonings.
ReplyDelete